What are the Final Four?

Deciding the contestants.

Here we go. I’m just going to go through the pile first and decide “no” or “maybe.” No yesses yet.

John Wesley Harding is a huge influence on me. Gorgeous record — one of the things I found inspiring was just the atmosphere of the thing. This one’s a “maybe.”

Absolutely Free is the one of the original trilogy that I’m least familiar with. I have copies of Freak Out and We’re Only In It For the Money. Both of which I like very much. Still, I’d have to seek out Absolutely Free on Youtube to hear it, which somehow seems less of an authentic way of doing this battle. I think they all have to be CDs so that format doesn’t affect my thinking. This one’s a “no.”

Piper at the Gates of Dawn is also a super-monolithic album for me. There are several Floyd albums that I rank as approximately equal to this one in value, And this is a first-tier Pink Floyd album. I’m going to call it a strong “maybe. “

Françoise Hardy’s Ma Jeunesse Fout le Camp might be of insterest. I think it’s a no but I definitely need to look it up. Her first album, Tous les garçons et les filles is one of my very favorite records. But for now, she’s a “no.”

Days of Future Passed is an album I’m less familiar with, but I’ve been listening to it quite a bit, lately, and I might just include it. Officially a “maybe.”

Disraeili Gears is the state-of-the-art heavy album of its time. It’s also a great psych album and a great blues/rock album. Very boy. “Maybe.”

Interstellar Space shocked me when I first heard it. This is avant-garde jazz at its most out-there. It is astrology-inspired free jazz made by a duo – Coltrane and drummer Rashied Ali. This is a strong “maybe.”

I think this The Nice CD is unlikely, unfortunately. Not a contender, I think, considering what else there is on this list. Still, I’m going to list it as a “maybe.” I think there are probably things I have more to say about, for instance —

Revolver. Quite honestly, I think this is the greatest rock album ever made. I’m listing it as a “maybe” but I am so tempted to just call it a yes. Spoiler alert, I guess.

Smiley Smile is as important to my sensibilites as a music fan as John Welsey Harding. This is also a maybe.

Of the two Byrds albums, I think I’m more likely to have something to say about Younger that Yesterday. Sweetheart of the Rodeo has been written about way more, and I resonate more with the psychedelic touches of YtY, so I will pick that over SotR.

So the “maybes” are

  • John Wesley Harding
  • Piper at the Gates of Dawn
  • Days of Future Passed
  • Disraeli Gears
  • Interstellar Space
  • Revolver
  • Smiley Smile
  • Younger than Yesterday

So let’s do brackets…

Bracket One: JWH v YtY. I’ll go with John Wesley Harding.

Bracket Two: Piper at the Gates of Dawn versus Disraeli Gears. I’ll go with the Floyd.

Bracket Three: Interstellar Space versus Smiley Smile. I’ll go with Smiley Smile. EDIT: Having trouble finding my copy on CD. Might have to go with Interstellar Space instead.

And finally…

Bracket Four: Revolver versus Days of Future Passed. I think I have more to say about that Beatles record. Maybe I’ll do a consolation battle…

But the official choices for this battle are:

Bob Dylan – John Wesley Harding
Pink Floyd – Piper at the Gates of Dawn
The Beach Boys – Smiley Smile
The Beatles – Revolver

Coming next: The Big Battle.

Annotated Short List for Album Battle 1967.

I’m gunna do an album battle. 700 words max.

  • The Beatles – Revolver. This one pretty much has to be in.
  • The Nice – The Thoughts of Emerlast Davjack. I need to hear this one a couple more times before I decide whether or not to include it.
  • John Coltrane – Interstellar Space. fabulous free jazz. Do I like this better than A Love Supreme?
  • Cream – Disraeli Gears. Perhaps the epitomy of heavy psych.
  • The Moody Blues – Days of Future Passed. Gorgeous record.
  • Pink Floyd – Piper at the Gates of Dawn. See Revolver.
  • Frank Zappa – Absolutely Free. Don’t have this one, though I’m sure I could rustle up a copy if I really wanted to.
  • Bob Dylan – John Wesley Harding. This one is a near-certainty. Very influential to my songwriting.
  • The Beach Boys – Smiley Smile. This album is one of the weirdest, yet most beautiful recordings ever made.
  • The Byrds – Younger than Yesterday. Chris Hillman’s last album with the band.
  • The Byrds – Sweetheart of the Rodeo. Gram Parsons. The one that usually gets written about.

I will narrow this list down to 4. That’s my next post.

Sometimes I Wonder if I Will Live to See the End of This Era.

A Show-and-Tell

If, if Reagan played disco
He’d shoot it to shit.
You can’t disco in jack boots.

High upon a white horse
He’d sing lame lyrics
To try to reach the working man.

–The Minutemen, 1982

That’s the entire lyrics to If Reagan Played Disco by southern California punk band the Minutemen, released as one of five songs on a seven inch vinyl record entitled “bean-spill e. p.”

Here’s my copy: Sorry, I will only be posting the non-obscene label here…

        

This cultural artifact from 43 years ago shows that the issues that seem so immediate and emergent right now have been with us for decades. The Republican conservative project has been the same for all this time. The Democratic response has been just that – a weak, ineffectual response. The Democrats initiate nothing. All they seem to do is talk in the least effective/offensive way about vaguely lefty ideas they never enact, while governing like diet Republicans.

The real response to what’s happening in the world now comes from outside the corporate infrastructure, in places like the LAVA Center, citizen political groups, spaces that hold independent artists, writers, musicians and other creatives, who exist outside that structure. We are purified in our intentions because we exist outside the mainstream.

The mission of mainstream cultural money and power is to blind us to what’s real, to create an artificially rarified sense of what qualifies as legitimate cultural contribution so that anything real – anything you’d recognize as coming from someone’s real life and intention is seen as substandard — grubby and grimy, faulty, unwashed and obscene.

Because the truth is obscene. We see the IDF shooting Palestinian children in the head, carpet bombing and starving an entire people out of existence. And in the Palestinian people we should see ourselves. The big money, the power of industry, and world leadership supplies the bullets to, as our president says, “finish the job.”

“The job” is to diminish working people, out of existence if necessary. Their mission is to fill us with artificial hopes and synthetic mass-manufactured bullshit dreams, all the while eroding all of the real value – the compassion and care, the pride, the willingness to work to better each other and ourselves together, the simple beauty of the world around us – and turn it all into a zero-sum game, a race to gobble up that which has more value if left alone, those things that will grow if nurtured but can only wither if exploited.

Our job is that nurturing, and we’re doing it now: sharing our hearts, hearing each other. It’s the same job the Minutemen were doing decades ago. “If Reagan Played Disco.” In those words, there is a dream. It’s the same dream that had that lone student standing in front of a line of tanks in Beijing not so long after this record was made.

Some say that student’s name was Wang Weilin. The Chinese government says there was no such person. It’s said he was 19 years old when he stood in front of those tanks. It’s said he was arrested for “political hooliganism,” whatever that means. Now, nobody can prove he existed or if he exists still, in some gulag somewhere. But we know who he is, because of what he did – what we all saw him do, even though his country’s government denies it ever happened.

D. Boon, the guitarist and singer of the Minutemen died in the band van when it rolled while they were on tour, three years after this record was released. These grooves are part of his corpse. After he died, his fellow band members George Hurley and Mike Watt continued on.

Years later, they recorded a drop-dead gorgeous instrumental called “Tien An Men Dream Again” as fIREHOSE, with guitarist Ed fROMOHIO.

Zeitgeist 3/5/25

Annie Haslam puts me in mind of Jacqui McShee

I’m listening to Renaissance’s Ashes are Burning from 1973. I read it as harkening back to Vanguard Records kinda stuff. Honestly, if you like Pentangle, you’re going to love this. Jon Camp is one of those Rick with a pick™ guys and is melodic in that Chris Squire/Paul McCartney way. Annie Haslam definitely puts me in mind of Jacqui McShee, but making mathy, orchestral music.

Really nice. I’m midway through side two of this thing, so I feel like I can say that this is a truly great pop/prog album.

I’m thinking about this theory Krystal Ball put forward that suggests that Trump may actually be trying to cause a recession. I think maybe so. Maybe that’s what’s happening.

Our options are these: he’s doing it intentionally OR he’s just that stupid. I don’t know which to believe. Much will be decided over the coming weeks. I’m praying that the upshot is that Trump is just a stupid muhfuggah, and that Elon Musk makes Pumpkin Spice Palpatine look like a friggin genius. (A big friggin OMG DUDE to whoever came up with the name “PayPalpatine” for Elon, btw.)

That’s my favorite conspiracy theory.

My LEAST favorite theory is that Trump is a Russian asset. I don’t believe it for a minute. Second worst possibility is that Trump and Putin see each other as equals, and Putin’s rule is the closest analogue to what Trump wants.

He might get it. <shrug>

Barrett by Syd Barrett

A reminder of what might have been

Syd Barrett was the original leading light of Pink Floyd, but succumbed to debilitating psychological issues that began around the time of the release of the band’s first album. He left the band under a cloud after a short struggle to continue contributing, and after two erratic solo albums, left the music business entirely. Barrett, his second solo album, was the end of the road for Syd as a recording artist.

It’s sssssooooo wwwwweeeeiiiirrrrrddddddddd, but it’s also surprisingly good considering the problems involved in making it, and different from anything else you might care to name in rock music.

The first thing I think of with Syd’s solo stuff is wild tempo shifts and a casual attitude towards pitch, but there’s less out-of-control-ness than you might think on Barrett. I mean, it’s loose, at times almost chaotic, but I think Syd was a lot more on top of things for this record than his rep might suggest.

“Gigolo Aunt,” for instance is prime late-sixties pop rock, as is “Baby Lemonade.” The shuffling beats, the psychedelic brightness, the unique phrasing and viewpoint — all are trademark, and testament to Barrett’s distinctive creativity.

The band is Syd on vocals and guitar, Richard Wright on keys, Jeff Shirley from Humble Pie on drums, and David Gilmour on bass and backing vocals. Gilmour and Wright are the producers. At Gilmour’s insistance, Syd plays all the guitars.

Ultimately, it’s both its own thing – loose and immediate, quirky and streamlined – and a reminder of what might have been.